Arkham Horror LCG – Review

Ever since Fantasy Flight Games announced Arkham Horror: The Card Game, a Lovecraftian themed game in the Living Card Game (LCG) format I had been interested. I have had a load of fun playing Eldritch Horror and the idea of a more compact game in that vein and co-operative to boot was to good a concept to pass up.
Before we dive into the meat of this we need to get one thing out of the way: you should play this game without reading any spoilers at all. I am going to avoid scenario spoilers completely in my review and I suggest when you open your game that you do not look through all the scenario cards. Doing so will spoil some enjoyment of the game. Let’s delve deep.

Deciphering the signs

A little explanation of this idea is probably worth it before going any further. The Living Card Game, or LCG, games are Fantasy Flight Games’ answer to the problem with Collectable Card Games, or CCG, model. The CCG model tends to revolve around a rarity system, where some cards are harder to get than others. People then buy cards in booster packs, where they know they will get a rare, some uncommon etc, but don’t know exactly what cards they will get. This means to play competitively you have to throw down some fairly serious money, Magic: The Gathering being the perfect example of this format.
LCGs do away with the randomness completely. You buy a starter set with a fixed number and selection of cards in it and then every month or so a new ‘pack’ comes out with 15 or so new cards with enough copies of each to put in your deck should you want to max out a particular card. However unlike the CCG model you know exactly what cards are in each pack and starter set, there is no ‘rare chasing’ as you see in Magic and the like. The slight issue here is that if you want a full playset, enough of every card to put in a deck, you usually need to buy more than one core set.
Both these models do mean that you will be doing a little work after opening up your game in that you’ll need to build you own deck. If that concept puts you off, don’t worry. There are plenty of resources to get ideas for decks and I am sure you will see the benefit of moulding your own particular deck as you get more familiar with the game.

Opening an Ancient Tome

Arkham Horror: The Card Game is a fascinating mash up of LCG concepts with an RPG underlay, a thrilling ride into the heart of madness as you try and prevent the world from falling to the Mythos. Cracking open the box you are greeted by several packs of beautifully illustrated cards and a bunch of chunky tokens, typical FFG excellent quality. A learn to play guide sits on top of the Rules Reference and you can dive straight in with the former, following it’s excellent instructions on how to build your first two decks.
You’ll first off all split these decks of cards into two seperate piles: all the ones to do with building your decks, the character cards and all the ones that the game is going to use to cause you trouble which include location, act, agenda and encounter cards. Do your very best not to look at any of this second set of cards until they are in play, your first experience with the game will be all the better for it.

Role with the punches

Arkham Horror: The Card Game sees you taking on the role, and I really do mean that, of an investigator in the strange little town of Arkham, Massachusetts. Things are going bump in the night and for one reason or another you and your fellow players have decided to venture out and figure out what is going on. The two decks the game sets you off into the unknown with are Roland Banks, the Fed, and Wendy Adams, the Orphan. Each of these characters comes with their own character card, mini card to show their position in the scenario and a few cards unique to them, we will come back to those momentarily.
Following the instructions in the Learn to Play guide you will throw two decks together. Each investigator fits into a class: Guardian, Survivor, Seeker, Mystic and Rogue. The intro decks see you putting together a Guardian/Seeker deck for Roland and a Survivor/Rogue deck for Wendy. Each class has it’s own particular specialisations and frankly I’m not going to spoil those for you as I am sure you will find the class(es) that suit you best.
Alongside the class cards you will put some neutral cards in, that have no class affiliation, and lastly the most important cards. I’ve touched already upon that each deck is an actual character in the game and it’s these final cards that really drive that point home. On the back of each character card is a little story as to how they got involved in the investigations into the Mythos. Roland is a Fed, so is looking into things in an official capacity. Unfortunately this means he has instructions to keep everything on the down low and his signature weakness ‘Cover up’ reflects this. On the other hand he hasn’t come without being prepared for the worst, and his guns are some of the best in the box. Unfortunately, hey it’s a reverse criticism sandwich, you also get another weakness alongside the signature one.
Although this only amounts to 3 cards out of a 33 card deck you will come to hate them like nothing else. During the game whenever you draw a weakness from your deck you have to reveal it and resolve it. Roland’s basically means that he has to go and burn some evidence somewhere. If you don’t succeed by the end of the scenario, Roland is going to have to wrestle with failing at his job for the rest of the game, taking a permanent mental damage through the subsequent scenarios. The basic weakness that the starter deck gives you on top of that means he loses all his resources, the currency you use to do EVERYTHING in the game. So yeah, they suck.

It was a cold dark night..

You have your decks ready to go and now it’s time to venture into the cold dark night and hope you don’t go mad. The core set of Arkham Horror contains a campaign called Night of the Zealot and 3 scenarios. You will start in the house of the lead investigator, suddenly trapped in his study you will desperately search for a way out when ……. let’s stop there Seriously I can’t say anymore without spoiling things for you.
Each scenario is a selection of location cards that the characters can move around. Each card has two sides so that the game can make you guess which version of a particular location is in play. On top of this is an encounter deck that you will be drawing from frequently. These encounters could be monsters, traps …. Guess what, spoilers. The real driving force behind each scenario is the Agenda and Aact deck. A’s each scenario opens, you will read a bit of intro text to get your characters on the same page. The top card of the Agenda and Act deck will also be read telling you, respectively, what the forces of evil are up to and how you can stop it.  The final piece of setup is the card that tells you about all the symbols in the chaos bag.
The Chaos Bag is a beautiful piece of design and really sets this game apart. Rather than rolling a dice, or pulling a card to resolve the many skill tests you will be faced with you pull a token from the bag, add it to your skill and compare to the target number. This sounds rather pedestrian but the beauty of the chaos bag is that the difficulty can be altered by removing 1 token and adding another. Not only that but the special symbols in the bag can do different things depending on the scenario, leaving a lot of room for variety in those pesky symbols. Who knows, over the course of a campaign you may even find the bag changes!
Over the course of the scenario Doom will slowly accumulate on the Agenda, flipping the agenda and causing all manner of things to happen. Investigators will accumulate clues and defeat things that go bump in the night, advancing the Act deck and getting them one step closer to the conclusion of the scenario before they lose their minds or their lives.
How these Act and Agenda cards interact with each other, the encounter deck and the locations deck is a delightful experience with surprises round every corner as the design team shows you what they can do with the space they have built. You will find each scenario can be completed in a variety of ways and what you do in one affects the next. On top of this each scenario will expose your character to the horrors of the mythos and leave them better prepared for what is to come. This manifests itself in experience which can used to change the cards in your deck. Maybe Wendy will upgrade the Lucky card in her deck for a better version, or perhaps Roland could really do with a Police Badge.
Although there are only 3 scenarios in the core I have played through them multiple times and each one has felt like a well defined interesting story. That is what this game delivers in spades. The co-op game lying at the core is great but more than that each attempt at this particular campaign feels like it’s own self contained story, no matter what happens.

This is not the end of your tale

Of course the LCG format does  mean that you will see a lot of content coming out for Arkham Horror: The Card Game. First off I would say that the core set is a really solid experience all on it’s own. Plenty of replayability in there if you just want to get a taste for the game. If you really enjoy it and want to build more consistent decks you are going to want a second copy of this core set, a bit of an investment but worth it if you want more of the deck building side of the game.
However, should you want to go further you can delve into the Mythos with the now complete Dunwich Legacy. Starting with a new core set of the same name it introduces 5 new investigators, one for each class, a bunch of new investigator cards and the 2 new scenarios. Where the core set gives you a taster of what the designers are capable of the 2 in this set blew my mind. After this core there are then 6 packs, each containing a slew of new cards for your Investigator deck and a new scenario making the full campaign 8 scenarios long. I will be reviewing each of these packs separately but I can tell you that I loved every minute of my first run through it and have swung back round for another go with different decks and at a harder difficulty.
But wait…there’s more. On the horizon, and releasing at Gencon will be the core set for Carcosa, starting a new 8 scenario campaign featuring a mysterious play and a neutral investigator!
Final thoughts of a doomed investigator
I have been immensely impressed with Arkham Horror: The Card Game. The rulebooks are some of the best that FFG have produced, and I would be the first to call them to task for such things and the cards and tokens are absolutely gorgeous. The designers have created a fascinating design space that they can now play with and they are already showing signs of having fun with that space. Arkham Horror: The Card Game is a huge amount of fun, with emergent stories, great decisions and fascinating design philosophy behind it. The Core Set is a  strong start for a game that has gone from strength to strength with the later expansions, and shows no signs of slowing down.

Iain McAllister

Tabletop games reviewer and podcaster based in Dalkeith, Scotland.

You may also like...

Leave a Reply

%d bloggers like this: